| Date | Our Pick | Result |
| Dec 22 2025 | Bethune Cookman at Arizona (Arizona -39) | loss |
| Dec 22 2025 | Davidson at Kansas (Kansas -15) | WINNER |
| Dec 22 2025 | Eastern Michigan at Wright State (Wright State -10.5) | loss |
| Dec 22 2025 | Eastern Washington at BYU (BYU -35) | loss |
| Dec 22 2025 | Missouri at Illinois (Illinois -9) | WINNER |
| Dec 22 2025 | Northern Iowa at St Marys (St Marys -11.5) | loss |
| Dec 22 2025 | Portland at UCSB (UCSB -9.5) | WINNER |
| Dec 22 2025 | Princeton at Temple (Princeton +8.5) | WINNER |
| Dec 22 2025 | San Diego at Washington (San Diego +18.5) | loss |
| Dec 22 2025 | Seattle at UTSA (Seattle -10.5) | loss |
| Dec 22 2025 | Stonehill at Syracuse (Syracuse -23.5) | WINNER |
| Dec 22 2025 | Washington State vs Utah State (Washington State +1) | WINNER |
| Dec 21 2025 | Cincinnati at Clemson (Cincinnati +3.5) | WINNER |
| Dec 21 2025 | Columbia at California (California -8.5) | WINNER |
| Dec 21 2025 | Fort Wayne at Notre Dame (Notre Dame -11.5) | loss |
|