| Date | Our Pick | Result |
| Jan 4 2026 | Bradley at Murray State (Murray State -5.5) | WINNER |
| Jan 4 2026 | Creighton at Seton Hall (Seton Hall -3.5) | loss |
| Jan 4 2026 | Indiana State at Drake (Drake -6.5) | loss |
| Jan 4 2026 | LMU at Gonzaga (Gonzaga -25) | WINNER |
| Jan 4 2026 | Marquette at U Conn (Marquette +17.5) | WINNER |
| Jan 4 2026 | New Mexico State at Missouri State (New Mexico State +1) | loss |
| Jan 4 2026 | Portland at San Francisco (San Francisco -11.5) | loss |
| Jan 4 2026 | Richmond at Fordham (Richmond -2.5) | WINNER |
| Jan 4 2026 | Robert Morris at Oakland (Oakland -2.5) | WINNER |
| Jan 4 2026 | San Diego at Santa Clara (Santa Clara -17.5) | WINNER |
| Jan 4 2026 | Seattle at St Marys (St Marys -11.5) | WINNER |
| Jan 4 2026 | Tulsa at North Texas (Tulsa -2.5) | loss |
| Jan 4 2026 | UIC at Valparaiso (Valparaiso -2.5) | WINNER |
| Jan 4 2026 | Washington at Indiana (Indiana -9) | WINNER |
| Jan 4 2026 | Wright State at Indianapolis (Indianapolis +8.5) | WINNER |
|