| Date | Our Pick | Result |
| Dec 29 2025 | Cornell at Michigan State (Cornell +24) | WINNER |
| Dec 29 2025 | Dartmouth at Florida (Dartmouth +35.5) | WINNER |
| Dec 29 2025 | Evansville at Bradley (Bradley -11.5) | loss |
| Dec 29 2025 | Georgia Southern at App State (Georgia Southern -10) | WINNER |
| Dec 29 2025 | Kent State at Purdue (Kent State +25.5) | loss |
| Dec 29 2025 | McNeese at Michigan (Michigan -24.5) | WINNER |
| Dec 29 2025 | Middle Tennessee at Houston (Middle Tennessee +26.5) | WINNER |
| Dec 29 2025 | Northern Kentucky at Robert Morris (Northern Kentucky -1) | WINNER |
| Dec 29 2025 | Oakland at Wright State (Wright State -3.5) | WINNER |
| Dec 29 2025 | South Dakota State at Arizona (Arizona -31) | loss |
| Dec 29 2025 | Southern at Illinois (Illinois -33.5) | WINNER |
| Dec 29 2025 | Southern Illinois at Murray State (Murray State -7) | loss |
| Dec 29 2025 | Southern Mississippi at LSU (LSU -20.5) | WINNER |
| Dec 29 2025 | U Mass Lowel at Iowa (U Mass Lowel +33.5) | WINNER |
| Dec 29 2025 | Utah at Washington (Washington -11.5) | loss |
|